segments

Does it make sense to follow Albertson's new "last mile" strategy?



<< Previous Next >>

Recommend This Post 215
Does it make sense to follow Albertson's new

Albertson’s recent decision to discontinue use of its own drivers and shift to third-party DoorDash for grocery delivery in certain markets makes it even more important for other grocers to consider how execution of “third-party” is changing – and in fact, moving beyond the typical players.

Today most folks equate third-party with Instacart; they are the biggest third-party provider in grocery and played an important role during the pandemic. Other third-party providers with similar approaches, like Shipt, UberEats, etc., also offer grocers a way to outsource delivery.

The big challenge for grocers offering delivery (by any method) is the costs it brings with it, and these costs must be lowered to make the delivery business profitable.  

Given this challenge, we anticipate that more grocers will get involved in the management of third-party delivery operations.

BMC POV

Beyond the typical third-party providers (Instacart, Shipt, DoorDash, etc.,) there are at least three additional third-party approaches that grocers can adopt to reduce cost and increase their control over delivery. These approaches include:

  • Outsourcing to a large third-party supplier like Budget Rent-a-Truck, that has the scale and business model to offer lower cost deliveries.
  • Outsourcing to several smaller third-party providers, different players in different markets, that have the cost advantages of market knowledge and established relationships.
  • DIY: Creating their own gig-driven business network in which the retailer bids out the work to individual operators. The good news is that today several software platforms enable retailers to streamline outsourcing this work and lower costs.

While not all grocers will get more involved in third-party providers, we are beginning to see more action and we expect activity to grow in all three areas in the near term.

 

Comments RSS

Joe Szala said:
This is not altogether surprising given the feedback I have received from grocery executives over the last 6 months, or incongruent with previously set Albertsons strategy. It all comes down to operational efficiency and profitability.

Sustaining their own fleet of vehicles and drivers to use them presents numerous challenges in regard to fill rates/route optimization and maximizing an 8-hour shift. There simply aren’t consistently enough orders to deliver at a given time, and too much peak/non-peak velocity throughout the day. Speed to customer lags as well. These gaps are a major blow to efficiencies and thus profitability.

The question becomes how best to tackle the problem, including the last mile fulfillment options mentioned in the article as well as delivery orchestration platforms. In regard to the latter, a big part of the equation is speed; if efficiency and profitability is the problem to solve for, how quickly can you have something up and running? There are a number of solutions in the market for orchestration and location based optimization, although some are quite a bit more of an undertaking than others. A 12-14 month integration vs. a 2-3 month can make a huge difference.

Add a Comment *